Wednesday, March 11, 2009

Review: Clairefontaine Hardcover Book

Clairefontaine Hardback Book

From the Lincoln Stationers website:

"Clairefontaine Hardcover Book

96 blank or ruled sheets (192 pages)
Exceptionally white ultra smooth vellum, 24 lb. pH neutral, acid-free paper, sturdy binding sewn with linen thread with laminated hard - waterproof covers.

Size: 6¾" x 8 5/8""

Note: My measurements put this book at 6 7/8" x 8 3/4"...

Clairefontaine Hardback Book

Larger and wider than a large Moleskine.

Clairefontaine Hardback Book

I look at any journal, and I can't help but compare it to the form factor of the Moleskine. Yes, the Clairefontaine has a hard cover. Yes, it has what is probably the most well known fountain pen friendly paper. No ink I have ever tried on it has feathered or bled. It's a slick surface, so inks do tend to take a little longer to dry on it. (Use blotter paper)

It's not my first choice for paper for two reasons; I'm not partial to bright white paper, and though the surface is very smooth, I can detect a slight drag when I write on it as though the paper has been coated with something.

It's got bright white paper compared to the Moleskine's ivory, and there is no elastic closure/back pocket. Plain and simple, it's a hard core book from a company that's serious about quality.

I like that there is a plain papered option. Great for drawing and doodling. Light watercolor washes are just ok on this paper. I wouldn't specifically recommend this paper for watercolor work.

Both the cover and the paper have squared edges. I prefer rounded edges on the paper because squared paper can dig into your hand as you reach the bottom of the page.

Clairefontaine Hardback Book

I'm getting used to books wider than a large Moleskine, but hold a gun to my head and I prefer a thinner journal.

The main reason for my wanting to try this book was to see whether or not it lies/opens flat. Sadly, it doesn't - the cover lies flat, the pages do not. If you are writing on a flat surface, (which I almost never do) you will have to write in/out of a hump. It's not a horrible hump, but it's still a hump. If you write on your leg like I do, (holding one side of the book flat at a time) then there's almost no hump at all.

Clairefontaine Hardback Book

While this book might not fit my specific needs, it's still a very well made book that contains some excellent quality paper. This book appears to be made sturdy enough to take a significant amount of abuse and should last a long time. The average retail price is about $13.

Clairefontaine Hardback Book

Buy them Here and Here.

2 comments:

eriquito said...

Thank you for this very helpful review, BiffyBeans. You've saved me both time and disappointment. (Not to mention some money =)

Biffybeans said...

Thank you eriquito for taking the time to leave your feedback. It's a great product, but it's not going to suit everyone's needs. Which is cool that there are just so many CHOICES out there! :o)